Benny's Pizza - 437 Route 209

IL Tesoro Ristorante & Pizzeria

Pizzarama

Luigi's Pizza & Restaurant

Trattoria Italiana Greenwood Lake (75 Windermere Ave)

Anthony's Famous Pizza

TJ's BanginBoli.Pizza

Sicilian Delight (Middletown)

Prima Pizza Cafe & Shipping

Vic's Pizza (108 Clinton Street)

OCTY'S Pizzeria

Yani's Pizzeria

Siena's Torteria Pizzeria

Village Pizzeria

4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant

Stuff'd Calzone

Frank’s Pizza & Restaurant

Midway's Villa Roma

Cosimo's Brick Oven Ristorante & Bar

Crust & Ember (109 NJ-23)

Badabing Pizzeria (28 County Rd 78)

Cosimo's Woodbury

Dollar Tree (174 N. Main St)

Pizza Station Route 94

Luca Pizza Cafe

Pizza Star

53 min

  •  $

 

Carlos' Pizzeria and Bar

Pizza Mia (Newburgh)

Brother Bruno's

Brooklyn Calzones (126 Windermere Avenue)

Dante's Pizzeria

Cosimo's on Union

DeMarco's Pizzeria & Restaurant Catering (1926 Union Valley Road)

Market Fresh of Middletown

Monroy's Pizza

Bella Luna Restaurant & Pizzeria

Silk Factory

Marcelino's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Skyline Pizzeria & Restaurant

Onewaycafe And Pizza (11 Mulberry Street)

Pellegrino & Son's Pizzeria

44 min

  •  $

 

Vacca's Pizza

Badabing Restaurant

Stella’s Pizzeria Restaurant

Villa Italia

Planet Pizza

Pizza Bella - Florida NY (8 S Main St)

Stella III (Wurtsboro)

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant & Pizzeria (19 W Main St)

Villa Positano

Frank's Pizza - West Milford

Franks Pizza & Restaurant (470 Route 211)

59 min

  •  $$

 

Little Italy Of Wantage

Franco's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Saporito Pizza

Colandrea Pizza King

Pizza Express (1 Meadow Road)

Joey's Pizza (Middletown)

Amore's Pizzeria & Restaurant

30 min

  •  $

 

Guido's Pizza Parlor (35 E Main St 3)

Amalfi Pizzeria & Restaurant

Bear Mountain Pizza and Cafe