4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant

Anthony's Famous Pizza

Sicilian Delight (Middletown)

Village Pizzeria

Luigi's Pizza & Restaurant

Onewaycafe And Pizza (11 Mulberry Street)

Marcelino's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Villa Italia

Dollar Tree (174 N. Main St)

Saporito Pizza

Cosimo's Brick Oven Ristorante & Bar

Prima Pizza Cafe & Shipping

Crust & Ember (109 NJ-23)

Silk Factory

Amore's Pizzeria & Restaurant

31 min

  •  $

 

Bella Luna Restaurant & Pizzeria

Vic's Pizza (108 Clinton Street)

Pizza Mia (Newburgh)

Luca Pizza Cafe

Guido's Pizza Parlor (35 E Main St 3)

Siena's Torteria Pizzeria

Dante's Pizzeria

OCTY'S Pizzeria

Colandrea Pizza King

Little Italy Of Wantage

Stuff'd Calzone

Pizza Station Route 94

Stella’s Pizzeria Restaurant

Pizza Express (1 Meadow Road)

Pizzarama

Franco's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

IL Tesoro Ristorante & Pizzeria

Franks Pizza & Restaurant (470 Route 211)

58 min

  •  $$

 

Cosimo's on Union

Pizza Star

49 min

  •  $

 

Cosimo's Woodbury

Frank’s Pizza & Restaurant

Badabing Pizzeria (28 County Rd 78)

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant & Pizzeria (19 W Main St)

Skyline Pizzeria & Restaurant

Monroy's Pizza

Villa Positano

Badabing Restaurant

Joey's Pizza (Middletown)

Midway's Villa Roma

TJ's BanginBoli.Pizza

DeMarco's Pizzeria & Restaurant Catering (1926 Union Valley Road)

Yani's Pizzeria

Carlos' Pizzeria and Bar

Frank's Pizza - West Milford

Pellegrino & Son's Pizzeria

40 min

  •  $

 

Market Fresh of Middletown

Brooklyn Calzones (126 Windermere Avenue)

Brother Bruno's

Planet Pizza

Vacca's Pizza

Benny's Pizza - 437 Route 209

Pizza Bella - Florida NY (8 S Main St)

Trattoria Italiana Greenwood Lake (75 Windermere Ave)

Amalfi Pizzeria & Restaurant

Bear Mountain Pizza and Cafe

Stella III (Wurtsboro)